← all cases

Compare PepsiCo and Coca-Cola on profitability.

ok
clarity
5/5
comparison
5/5
evidence
5/5
honesty
5/5
faithfulness
5.0/5
elapsed
0.8s

Report

Profitability

PepsiCo and Coca-Cola are both highly profitable beverage-and-snack giants, but their profitability profiles differ meaningfully in scale, margin structure, and recent trajectory. PEP is the larger business by revenue—$91.9B in FY2024 [PEP:Q2] versus KO's $47.1B [KO:Q2]—yet KO consistently converts a higher share of revenue into profit. KO's gross margin runs well above PEP's: in FY2025, KO generated $29.5B of gross profit on $47.9B of revenue [KO:Q15][KO:Q3], implying ~62% gross margin, while PEP produced $50.9B of gross profit on $93.9B of revenue [PEP:Q15][PEP:Q3], implying ~54% gross margin—a gap that reflects PEP's heavier exposure to lower-margin food and snack manufacturing. At the operating income level, KO's FY2025 result of $13.8B [KO:Q11] on roughly half PEP's revenue base implies an operating margin of ~29%, compared with PEP's $11.5B [PEP:Q11] on nearly double the revenue, implying ~12%. Net income tells a similar story: KO earned $13.1B in FY2025 [KO:Q7] versus PEP's $8.2B [PEP:Q7], a notable reversal given PEP's much larger top line.

On revenue trajectory, both companies have expanded their top lines over the FY2022–FY2025 window, though the path has not been uniformly smooth. PEP grew from $86.4B in FY2022 [PEP:Q0] to $93.9B in FY2025 [PEP:Q3], but FY2023-to-FY2024 growth was essentially flat (~0.4%), making "steady growth" an overstatement for that stretch. KO's revenue similarly expanded over the period, though from a smaller base.

Profitability trends at the two companies have diverged recently. PEP's net income declined from $9.6B in FY2024 [PEP:Q6] to $8.2B in FY2025 [PEP:Q7], and this deterioration is broader than the bottom line alone suggests: operating income also fell sharply, from approximately $12.9B to $11.5B [PEP:Q11] (~-11%), even as revenue continued to grow—pointing to margin compression that appears more structural than transitory. KO's net income rose to $13.1B in FY2025 [KO:Q7] from $10.6B in FY2024 [KO:Q6]; however, it is worth noting that KO's net income had been roughly flat between FY2023 and FY2024, so the FY2025 jump represents a step-change rather than a continuation of a multi-year upward trend. The ~38% increase in KO's operating income over the same period may also reflect non-recurring items, and should be interpreted with some caution until the drivers are fully disclosed. Taken together, KO's margin expansion has been more pronounced in the most recent year, while PEP faces meaningful near-term profitability headwinds.

PEP: PepsiCo is a revenue powerhouse, growing from $86.4B in FY2022 [PEP:Q0] to $93.9B in FY2025 [PEP:Q3], but its diversified food-and-beverage model constrains margins relative to KO, with gross margins in the mid-50% range and operating margins around 12–14%. Net income declined from $9.6B in FY2024 [PEP:Q6] to $8.2B in FY2025 [PEP:Q7], and the accompanying drop in operating income—despite continued top-line growth—suggests the profitability pressure is broader and more structural than the net income line alone implies.

KO: Coca-Cola's asset-light, concentrate-focused model delivers structurally superior margins: gross profit reached $29.5B on $47.9B of revenue in FY2025 [KO:Q15][KO:Q3], implying ~62% gross margin, and operating income of $13.8B [KO:Q11] implies an operating margin near 29%. Net income rose to $13.1B in FY2025 [KO:Q7] from $10.6B in FY2024 [KO:Q6], though this follows a period of flat net income between FY2023 and FY2024, and the magnitude of the FY2025 improvement may partly reflect non-recurring factors. Even with those caveats, KO's profitability profile—higher margins at every level on roughly half PEP's revenue—remains structurally stronger.


Critic flags (4)

weakly_supportedprofitability
KO's [net income] surged from $10.6B in FY2024 to $13.1B in FY2025, widening the gap further
The FY2024→FY2025 net income increase is numerically correct, but the analysis omits that KO net income actually declined from FY2023 ($10.714B) to FY2024 ($10.631B), so FY2024 was not part of a rising trend. The ~38% jump in KO operating income over the same period also warrants disclosure of potential non-recurring drivers.
weakly_supportedprofitability
PEP's FY2025 net income declined from its FY2024 peak of $9.6B
The net income decline is confirmed ($9.578B → $8.240B), but the analysis does not disclose that PEP operating income also fell sharply ($12.887B → $11.498B, ~-10.8%) despite revenue growth, indicating the profitability deterioration is broader and more structural than the net income line alone suggests.
weakly_supportedprofitability
Both companies have grown revenues steadily since FY2022
Directionally true over the full FY2022–FY2025 window, but PEP's FY2023→FY2024 revenue growth was only ~0.4% ($91.471B to $91.854B), which is more accurately described as stagnation than steady growth.
unsupportedprofitability
Citations block references only PEP:us-gaap:Revenues and PEP:us-gaap:NetIncomeLoss for all quantitative claims
Roughly half the numerical claims in the analysis relate to KO, and gross profit and operating income figures for both companies are cited inline but absent from the formal citation list, making those claims unverifiable from the citation trail alone.

Cross-axis notes

KO's ~38% operating income surge from FY2024 ($9.992B) to FY2025 ($13.762B) is anomalous relative to its ~1.9% revenue growth over the same period. Any cross-axis analysis of capital allocation, earnings quality, or segment performance should investigate whether this reflects non-recurring gains rather than durable operational improvement.
PEP's operating income declined ~10.8% from FY2024 to FY2025 on modestly growing revenue, implying meaningful cost or mix headwinds. This is relevant to any axis covering cost structure, pricing power, volume/mix trends, or competitive dynamics and should be surfaced in those analyses.

Citations (32)

quant PEP FY2022
us-gaap:Revenues = $86.39B
quant PEP FY2023
us-gaap:Revenues = $91.47B
quant PEP FY2024
us-gaap:Revenues = $91.85B
quant PEP FY2025
us-gaap:Revenues = $93.92B
quant PEP FY2022
us-gaap:NetIncomeLoss = $8.91B
quant PEP FY2023
us-gaap:NetIncomeLoss = $9.07B
quant PEP FY2024
us-gaap:NetIncomeLoss = $9.58B
quant PEP FY2025
us-gaap:NetIncomeLoss = $8.24B
quant PEP FY2022
us-gaap:OperatingIncomeLoss = $11.51B
quant PEP FY2023
us-gaap:OperatingIncomeLoss = $11.99B
quant PEP FY2024
us-gaap:OperatingIncomeLoss = $12.89B
quant PEP FY2025
us-gaap:OperatingIncomeLoss = $11.50B
quant PEP FY2022
us-gaap:GrossProfit = $45.82B
quant PEP FY2023
us-gaap:GrossProfit = $49.59B
quant PEP FY2024
us-gaap:GrossProfit = $50.11B
quant PEP FY2025
us-gaap:GrossProfit = $50.86B
quant KO FY2022
us-gaap:Revenues = $43.00B
quant KO FY2023
us-gaap:Revenues = $45.75B
quant KO FY2024
us-gaap:Revenues = $47.06B
quant KO FY2025
us-gaap:Revenues = $47.94B
quant KO FY2022
us-gaap:NetIncomeLoss = $9.54B
quant KO FY2023
us-gaap:NetIncomeLoss = $10.71B
quant KO FY2024
us-gaap:NetIncomeLoss = $10.63B
quant KO FY2025
us-gaap:NetIncomeLoss = $13.11B
quant KO FY2022
us-gaap:OperatingIncomeLoss = $10.91B
quant KO FY2023
us-gaap:OperatingIncomeLoss = $11.31B
quant KO FY2024
us-gaap:OperatingIncomeLoss = $9.99B
quant KO FY2025
us-gaap:OperatingIncomeLoss = $13.76B
quant KO FY2022
us-gaap:GrossProfit = $25.00B
quant KO FY2023
us-gaap:GrossProfit = $27.23B
quant KO FY2024
us-gaap:GrossProfit = $28.74B
quant KO FY2025
us-gaap:GrossProfit = $29.54B