← all cases

Compare Microsoft and Alphabet on profitability.

ok
clarity
5/5
comparison
5/5
evidence
4/5
honesty
5/5
faithfulness
5.0/5
elapsed
0.7s

Report

Profitability

Both Microsoft and Alphabet have demonstrated strong and accelerating profitability over the multi-year period covered by the evidence, though they differ meaningfully in scale, margin structure, and trajectory.

On the revenue side, GOOGL is larger in absolute terms, reaching $402.8B in FY2025 [GOOGL:Q2] versus MSFT's $281.7B [MSFT:Q3], reflecting Alphabet's dominant advertising and cloud businesses. However, MSFT's operating margin is notably higher: its FY2025 operating income of $128.5B [MSFT:Q11] on $281.7B of revenue [MSFT:Q3] implies an operating margin of roughly 46%, compared to GOOGL's $129.0B operating income [GOOGL:Q10] on $402.8B of revenue [GOOGL:Q2], implying roughly 32%. MSFT's gross profit of $193.9B in FY2025 [MSFT:Q15] on that same revenue base underscores its high-margin software and cloud mix.

On net income, GOOGL has pulled ahead in absolute dollars, earning $132.2B in FY2025 [GOOGL:Q6] versus MSFT's $101.8B [MSFT:Q7]. This represents a meaningful shift from FY2022, when MSFT held a roughly $12.8B net income advantage ($72.7B [MSFT:Q4] vs. $60.0B [GOOGL:Q3]), with the two companies converging to near-parity by FY2023 ($72.4B [MSFT:Q5] vs. $73.8B [GOOGL:Q4]) before GOOGL extended its lead through FY2025.

Both companies have seen operating income grow substantially over this period—MSFT's rising from $83.4B in FY2022 [MSFT:Q8] to $128.5B in FY2025 [MSFT:Q11] (a gain of approximately $45.1B), while GOOGL's climbed from $74.8B in FY2022 [GOOGL:Q7] to $129.0B in FY2025 [GOOGL:Q10] (a gain of approximately $54.2B). On a purely quantitative basis, GOOGL's operating income growth has been somewhat steeper over this window, though both trajectories reflect substantial earnings power.

Note: GOOGL figures (revenue, operating income, net income) are drawn from Alphabet's filings and verified as correct, though explicit inline citation identifiers for GOOGL are less fully documented in the underlying source material than those for MSFT.


MSFT: Microsoft exhibits exceptional profitability margins, with FY2025 operating income of $128.5B [MSFT:Q11] on revenue of $281.7B [MSFT:Q3] implying an operating margin near 46%, supported by a gross profit of $193.9B [MSFT:Q15] that reflects its high-margin cloud and software mix. Net income has grown steadily from $72.7B in FY2022 [MSFT:Q4] to $101.8B in FY2025 [MSFT:Q7], demonstrating durable earnings power even as the company invests heavily in AI infrastructure.

GOOGL: Alphabet has seen a dramatic profitability inflection, with net income surging from $60.0B in FY2022 [GOOGL:Q3] to $132.2B in FY2025 [GOOGL:Q6], now exceeding Microsoft's in absolute terms. Operating income reached $129.0B in FY2025 [GOOGL:Q10] on revenues of $402.8B [GOOGL:Q2], though the implied operating margin of roughly 32% trails Microsoft's, reflecting Alphabet's heavier revenue base in lower-margin advertising and its ongoing investments across cloud and Other Bets.


Critic flags (3)

weakly_supportedprofitability
a reversal from FY2023 when the two were nearly tied ($73.8B [GOOGL] vs. $72.4B [MSFT])
While the FY2023 figures are accurate, framing FY2023 as the first point of near-parity is misleading. In FY2022, MSFT net income was $72.738B vs. GOOGL's $59.972B — a $12.8B gap in MSFT's favor. The 'reversal' therefore happened between FY2022 and FY2023, not merely at FY2023, and the analyst's narrative omits this context.
weakly_supportedprofitability
GOOGL's acceleration has been steeper in recent years, driven by Search resilience and Google Cloud momentum
The quantitative acceleration claim is supportable (GOOGL operating income grew ~$54.2B from FY2022–FY2025 vs. MSFT's ~$45.1B), but the qualitative attribution to 'Search resilience and Google Cloud momentum' is not grounded in any cited filing text within this axis — it is an analyst assertion without a filing citation.
weakly_supportedprofitability
Citations reference only MSFT XBRL concepts; GOOGL figures carry no listed citations
The citation block lists only MSFT quant sources (RevenueFromContractWithCustomerExcludingAssessedTax, NetIncomeLoss). All GOOGL figures (revenue, operating income, net income) are unaccompanied by explicit citations in the axis output, creating a documentation gap even though the numbers themselves are verified as correct from filings.

Cross-axis notes

The profitability axis notes GOOGL's acceleration is driven by 'Search resilience and Google Cloud momentum' — this qualitative claim is not grounded in any cited filing text within this axis and would need support from a segment or MD&A axis.
MSFT FY2022 net income ($72.738B) was actually higher than GOOGL FY2022 net income ($59.972B), meaning the net income 'reversal' began earlier than FY2023; the analyst's framing that the two were 'nearly tied' only in FY2023 understates the magnitude of GOOGL's catch-up from FY2022.

Citations (27)

quant MSFT FY2022
us-gaap:RevenueFromContractWithCustomerExcludingAssessedTax = $198.27B
quant MSFT FY2023
us-gaap:RevenueFromContractWithCustomerExcludingAssessedTax = $211.91B
quant MSFT FY2024
us-gaap:RevenueFromContractWithCustomerExcludingAssessedTax = $245.12B
quant MSFT FY2025
us-gaap:RevenueFromContractWithCustomerExcludingAssessedTax = $281.72B
quant MSFT FY2022
us-gaap:NetIncomeLoss = $72.74B
quant MSFT FY2023
us-gaap:NetIncomeLoss = $72.36B
quant MSFT FY2024
us-gaap:NetIncomeLoss = $88.14B
quant MSFT FY2025
us-gaap:NetIncomeLoss = $101.83B
quant MSFT FY2022
us-gaap:OperatingIncomeLoss = $83.38B
quant MSFT FY2023
us-gaap:OperatingIncomeLoss = $88.52B
quant MSFT FY2024
us-gaap:OperatingIncomeLoss = $109.43B
quant MSFT FY2025
us-gaap:OperatingIncomeLoss = $128.53B
quant MSFT FY2022
us-gaap:GrossProfit = $135.62B
quant MSFT FY2023
us-gaap:GrossProfit = $146.05B
quant MSFT FY2024
us-gaap:GrossProfit = $171.01B
quant MSFT FY2025
us-gaap:GrossProfit = $193.89B
quant GOOGL FY2023
us-gaap:Revenues = $307.39B
quant GOOGL FY2024
us-gaap:Revenues = $350.02B
quant GOOGL FY2025
us-gaap:Revenues = $402.84B
quant GOOGL FY2022
us-gaap:NetIncomeLoss = $59.97B
quant GOOGL FY2023
us-gaap:NetIncomeLoss = $73.80B
quant GOOGL FY2024
us-gaap:NetIncomeLoss = $100.12B
quant GOOGL FY2025
us-gaap:NetIncomeLoss = $132.17B
quant GOOGL FY2022
us-gaap:OperatingIncomeLoss = $74.84B
quant GOOGL FY2023
us-gaap:OperatingIncomeLoss = $84.29B
quant GOOGL FY2024
us-gaap:OperatingIncomeLoss = $112.39B
quant GOOGL FY2025
us-gaap:OperatingIncomeLoss = $129.04B